OCR of Document 44, Exhibit I - Margolin FOIA Withheld Index

 

There may be OCR errors that have escaped my proofreading, so refer to the original document before quoting.

 

Errors in the original document have been left uncorrected.  (“administrative” is sometimes spelled “admininstrative” and “forward” is sometimes spelled “foward”)

 

The table page numbers at the bottom of the page have been left off. References to pages should use the Court page number at the top of the page (which are not in the html version).

 

- Jed Margolin

 

 

Exhibit I

 

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

2

00001

00016

No Date

N/A

N/A

 

Admin claim for

infringement of U.S.

Patent 5,904,724 -

NASA Case No. I-222

 

(b)(5)

NASA attorney's initial working drafts of agency

response to infringement claim

3

00034

00035

1/25/2007

Borda

Homer/Kennedy

 

General Atomics

Aeronautical Systems

and NASA

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorney requesting legal guidance

4

00038

00038

8/5/2008

McNutt

Borda/Rotella

Sherman

Jed Margolin's Patent

Infringement Claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys. Reports phone conversation between

NASA attorney and Margolin re: patent

infringement claim

5

00039

00039

8/5/2008

RFR

McNutt

Borda

Pending or

Threatened Litigation

Report

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys. Question re whether Optima's

demand letter should be listed in threatened

litigation in OGC report

6

00040

00041

8/6/2008

Borda

McNutt/Rotella

Sherman

Jed Margolin's Patent

Infringement Claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys giving guidance on statute of

limitations for patent infringement claims

7

00042

00042

8/5/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA

8

00047

00047

8/6/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA

9

00047

00047

8/6/2008

McNutt

Adams

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA

10

00048

00048

8/5/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA

11

00048

00048

8/4/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA


 

 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

12

00048

00048

8/5/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA

13

00051

00053

8/6/2008

Borda

McNutt

 

Offer to Compromise

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorney re on licensing or compromising claim

14

00051

00053

8/6/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Response to your

most recent letter

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to settle administrative

claim with NASA (contained in B5 set: 00051‑

00052)

15

00054

00056

8/6/2008

Borda

McNutt

 

Offer to Compromise

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorney re licensing or compromising claim

16

00054

00056

8/6/2008

McNutt

Adams

 

Response to your

most recent letter

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA

17

00058

00058

2/10/2004

Kennedy

Fein

 

Admin Claim for

patent infringing of

patent 5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

Internal letter from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys requesting investigation of

admininstrative claim.

18

00116

00134

N/A

Rapid Imaging Software, Inc.

NASA Office of General Counsel

 

 

 

b(4)

 

Privileged attorney work product reflecting

claims analysis in light of prior art.

 

19

00126

00130

3/13/2009

McNutt

Hammerle

Borda/Ray/Graham

 

Optima denial letter

Optima denial

letter final

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys forwarding revisions to letter denying

admininstrative claim

20

00135

00137

8/6/2008

Borda

McNutt

 

Offer to Compromise

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing assignment documents

21

00135

00137

8/6/2008

Borda

McNutt

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

22

00146

00161

8/12/2008

McNutt

Borda

 

Analysis of Patent No.

5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys forwarding infringement analysis of

Patent No, 5,666,073

23

00162

00163

8/12/2008

McNutt

Galus/Rotella

Blackburn/Borda

Analysis of Patent No.

5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing legal issues re infringement

claim among NASA attorneys

24

00164

00166

8/12/2008

Galus

McNutt

Blackburn/Borda/

Rotella

Analysis of Patent No.

5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing legal issues re infringement

claim among NASA attorneys

25

00167

00169

8/14/2008

McNutt

Galus

Blackburn/Borda/

Rotella

Analysis of Patent No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing legal issues re infringement

claim among NASA attorneys

26

00170

00173

8/14/2008

Galus

McNutt

Blackburn/Borda/

Rotella/Madrid/

Mark/Goetzke

Analysis of Patent No.

5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing legal issues re infringement

claim and Margolin FOIA request among NASA

attorneys

27

00174

00177

8/14/2008

McNutt

Galus

Blackburn/Borda/

Rotella/Madrid/

Mark/Goetzke

Analysis of Patent No.

5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing legal issues re infringement

claim among NASA attorneys

28

00178

00181

8/18/2008

McNutt

Fein

Borda/Rotella/Galus

Analysis of Patent No.

5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing legal issues re infringement

claim among NASA attorneys

29

00185

00188

8/19/2008

Rotella

McNutt

Borda

Letter to Optima

Optima Letter

20080817

(b)(5)

NASA attorney's initial working draft of letter to

Optima requesting information re admininstrative

claim

30

00189

00192

8/19/2008

Fein

McNutt

Borda/Rotella/Galus/Ro/

Hammerle

Analysis of Patent No.

5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing legal issues re infringement

claim among NASA attorneys

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

31

00193

00197

8/19/2008

McNutt

Fein

Borda/Rotella/Galus/

Ro/Hammerle

Analysis of Patent No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing legal issues re infringement

claim among NASA attorneys

32

00238

00238

9/30/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA

33

00239

00240

9/30/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

administrative claim with NASA

34

00241

00242

10/6/09

McNutt

Rotella

Borda

FW: Optima Technology Group - Margolin Patents

 

b(4)

Email from NASA counsel fowarding

communication containing privileged attorney

work product provided by RIS.

35

00243

00258

NA

Rapid Imaging

Software, Inc.

NASA Office of

General Counsel

 

 

 

b(4)

Technical document, the identification of which

reflects the privileged legal opinion and attorney

work product of RIS in evaluating the validity of

certain patent claims.

36

00266

00354

NA

Rapid Imaging

Software, Inc.

NASA Office of

General Counsel

 

 

 

b(4)

Technical document, the identification of which

reflects the privileged legal opinion and attorney

work product of IRIS in evaluating the validity of

certain patent claims.

37

00339

00340

10/3/2008

Rotella

McNutt

Borda

Response to letter

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re evaluation of admininstrative claim

38

00355

00359

NA

Rapid Imaging

Software, Inc.

NASA Office of

General Counsel

 

 

 

b(4)

Privileged attorney work product reflecting

claims analysis in light of prior art.

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

39

00363

00364

10/16/2008

Borda

Fein/Homer

McNutt/Rotella/

Samuels,

Admin Claim for

patent infringement - Optima

Patent No. 5,904,724

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA attorneys sent to NASA attorneys discussing patent infringement claim

40

00635

00637

10/21/2008

Borda

Homer/Fein

Rotella

UAV patent infringement issue

Patent No.5,904,724

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA attorneys re evaluation of admininstrative claim

41

00669

00671

10/23/2008

Rotella

Homer

Borda

UAV patent infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing interpretation of patent claims

42

00672

00674

10/23/2008

Homer

Rotella

Borda

UAV patent infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing interpretation of patent claims

43

00675

00675

10/24/2008

Rotella

Del Frate

Homer/Borda

UAV patent infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing interpretation of patent claims

44

00676

00676

10/28/2008

Del Prate

Rotella

Homer/Borda

UAV patent infringement issue

US Patent UAV comments

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing interpretation of patent claims with NASA technical expert

45

00694

00695

10/31/2008

Borda

Sherman

 

Auditor's letter

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorney discussing reporting of administrative claim to NASA auditors

46

00696

00699

10/31/2008

Fein

Delgado

 

UAV patent infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

technical expert re evaluation of administrative claim re Patent No. 5,904,724

47

00713

00717

10/31/2008

Fein

Delgado

Fredrickson/

Martinez

UAV patent infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

technical expert re evaluation of administrative claim re Patent No. 5,904,724

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

48

00718

00718

11/13/2008

Borda

Rotella/McNutt

Fein/Homer

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys reviewing status of claim

49

00719

00719

11/13/2008

Fein

Delgado

Fredrickson/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotell

a/McNutt

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

technical expert requesting info on status of

review of admininstrative claim

50

00720

00720

11/17/2008

McNutt

Borda

 

Optima admininstrative claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney requesting

Info on status of review of admininstrative claim

51

00722

00723

12/16/2008

McNutt

Fein/Delgado

Frederickson/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotella

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys requesting info on status of review of

admininstrative claim

52

00724

00725

12/16/2008

Fein

Delgado

 

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

technical expert requesting info on status of

review of admininstrative claim

53

00726

00727

1/21/2009

McNutt

Delgado

Frederick/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotella/Fein

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

technical expert requesting info on status of

review of admininstrative claim

54

00728

00729

1/21/2009

Delgado

McNutt

Frederickson/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotella/Fein

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to

NASA attorney re evaluation of admininstrative

claim

55

00730

00730

1/22/2009

McNutt

Borda

Rotella/Graham

Margolin claim and

FOIA

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys reporting phone conversation with

Margolin

56

00731

00731

1/22/2009

Graham

McNutt/Borda

Rotella/Graham

Margolin claim and

FOIA

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys requesting progress info on

admininstrative claim

57

00732

00732

1/23/2009

McNutt

Graham/Borda

Rotella/Graham

Margolin claim and

FOIA

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys requesting progress info on

admininstrative claim

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

58

00733

00734

1/21/2009

Delgado

McNutt

Frederickson/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotel la/Fein

Margolin claim and FOIA

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to

NASA attorney reporting on his schedule re evaluation of admininstrative claim

59

00735

00737

1/23/2009

Delgado

McNutt

Frederickson/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotella/Fein

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to NASA attorneys analyzing patent claims

60

00738

00741

1/23/2009

McNutt

Delgado/Hammerle

Frederickson/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotel la/Fein

Optima admin claim

Del Frate's comments

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

technical expert providing guidance on patent claim analysis

61

00742

00755

1/23/2009

Rotella

McNutt

 

Del Frate's comments

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys forwarding analysis of patent claims by NASA technical expert

62

00756

00760

1/23/2009

Borda

Hammerle

McNutt/Rotella

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys forwarding analysis of patent claims by NASA technical expert

63

00761

00774

1/23/2009

Rotella

McNutt

 

Del Frate's comments

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys forwarding analysis of patent claims by NASA technical expert

64

00775

00776

1/16/2008

Borda

Fein/Homer

McNutt/Rotella/

Samuels

Admin Claim for

patent infringement -Optima

Patent No 5,904,724

(b)(5)

internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys requesting assistance in processing admininstrative claim

65

00777

00779

10/21/2008

Borda

Homer/Fein

Rotella/Graham

UAV patent infringement issue

Patent No 5,904,724

(b)(5)

internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys requesting assistance in processing admininstrative claim

66

00780

00784

10/31/2008

Fein

Delgado

Fredereickson/

Martinez

UAV patent infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

Technical expert requesting assistance from NASA technical expert in evaluating admininstrative claim

 

 


 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

67

00785

00788

1/23/2009

Delgado

McNutt/Hammerle

Frederickson/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotella/Fein

 

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to

NASA attorney with analysis of patent claims

68

00789

00793

1/28/2009

Hammerle

Delgado

Frederickson/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotella/Fein/

McNutt

Optima admin claim

Claims chart of

U.S. Patent No.

5,904,724

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

technical expert providing guidance on claim

interpretation

69

00799

00809

1/29/2009

Delgado

Hammerle

Frederickson/

Martinez/Borda/

Rotella/Fein/McNutt/

Delgado

Optima admin claim

Delgado feedback claims chart of U.S.

Patent 5,904,724

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to

NASA attorney containing analysis of patent

claims

70

00838

00838

1/5/2009

Hammerle

McNutt/Rotella

Fein/Borda

Updated status on

Margolin patent

infringement claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing status of patent claim

analysis by NASA technical expert

71

00839

00839

1/6/2009

McNutt

Hammerle/Rotella

Fein/Borda

Updated status on

Margolin patent

infringement claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing status of patent claim 

analysis by NASA technical expert

72

00840

00841

1/6/2009

Borda

Hammerle/McNutt/

Rotella

Fein/Graham

Updated status on

Margolin patent

infringement claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing status of patent claim

analysis by NASA technical expert

73

00842

00846

2/6/2009

Borda

Hammerle

Rotella/Fein/McNutt

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys requesting copies of documents

prepared by NASA technical expert

74

00847

00848

2/6/2009

Fein

Borda/Hammerle/

McNutt/Rotella

Graham

Updated status on

Margolin patent

infringement claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing status of patent claim

analysis by NASA technical expert

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

75

00849

00853

2/6/2009

Hammerle

Borda

 

Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing status of patent claim analysis by NASA technical expert

76

00912

00913

2/11/2009

Delgado

McNutt/Hammerle

Rotella/Borda/

Graham

Margolin claim

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to NASA attorney discussing admininstrative claim

77

00914

00916

2/13/2009

McNutt

Graham/Borda/

Rotella

 

Response to your most recent letter

Cobham 03 Feb 09.wav

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re progress on evaluating

admininstrative claim. Includes recording of

phone message forwarded by Adams re licensing patent

78

00915

00915

10/1/2008

McNutt

Adams

 

Response to your most recent letter

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to settle administrative

claim with NASA (contained in B5 set: 00914‑00916)

79

00916

00916

9/30/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Response to your most recent letter

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to settle administrative

claim with NASA (contained in B5 set: 00914‑00916)

80

00917

00920

2/13/2009

McNutt

Rotella/Graham/

Borda

 

Response to your most recent letter

 

(b)(5)

internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re progress on evaluating admininstrative claim

81

00919

00919

10/1/2008

McNutt

Adams

 

Response to your most recent letter

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to settle administrative

claim with NASA (contained in B5 set: 01140‑01148)

82

00921

00924

2/13/2009

McNutt

Hammerle

Fein/Rotella/

Borda

Margolin

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re progress on evaluating admininstrative claim

83

00923

00923

9/30/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise administrative claim with NASA

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

84

00925

00925

2/19/2009

Kathy Bayer

Borda

 

Hammerle

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA legal assistant to NASA

attorney reporting progress on evaluation of

admininstrative claim by NASA technical expert

85

00926

00927

2/20/2009

Hammerle

Rotella/McNutt

Borda/Fein/

Delgado

File wrapper for

5904724

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re evaluation of admininstrative claim

86

00928

00929

2/20/2009

Delgado

Fein/Hammerle/

Rotella/McNutt

Borda

File wrapper for

5904724

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to

NASA attorneys re evaluation of admininstrative claim

87

00930

00932

2/23/2009

Borda

Hammerle/Rotella/

McNutt

Fein

File wrapper for

5904724

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re evaluation of admininstrative claim

88

00933

00935

2/23/2009

Delgado

Hammerle/Rotella/

McNutt

Borda/Fein

File wrapper for

5904724

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to

NASA attorneys re evaluation of admininstrative claim

89

00936

00946

2/23/2009

Hammerle

Rotella/McNutt

Borda/Fein/

Delgado

File wrapper for

5904724

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re evaluation of admininstrative claim

90

00947

00950

2/24/2009

Borda

Hammerle/Rotella/

McNutt

Fein/Graham/

Delgado

File wrapper for

5904724

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re evaluation of admininstrative claim

91

00951

00954

2/24/2009

Delgado

Hammerle/Rotella/

McNutt

Borda/Fein

File wrapper for

5904724

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to

NASA attorneys evaluating admininstrative claim

92

00988

00991

3/6/2009

Rotella

Hammerle

Borda/McNutt/

Graham

File wrapper for

5904724

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing additional data for

evaluating admininstrative claim

 

 


 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

93

00992

00995

3/6/2009

Hammerle

Rotella

Fein/Borda/McNutt

File wrapper for

5904724

Pat - 00016

Margolin

5,904,724-G2

(L-0062086)

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys discussing additional data for

evaluating admininstrative claim

94

01091

01096

3/9/2009

Rotella

Borda/Graham/

McNutt

Hammerle

Draft letter denying

Optima/Margolin

admin claim

Draft Optima

denial letter

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys forwarding draft of letter denying

admininstrative claim

95

01097

01103

3/12/2009

Borda

Rotella/McNutt

 

Admin claim

Optima denial

letter BR draft

Borda rev

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys forwarding draft of letter denying

admininstrative claim

96

01104

01104

3/12/2009

McNutt

Delgado

Hammerle/Fein/

Rotella/Borda

Margolin patent

infringement claim -

X38

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

technical expert requesting information re

admininstrative claim

97

01105

01111

3/12/2009

McNutt

Borda/Rotella

Graham

Optima Denial Letter

BR draft - Borda-JSM

Rev

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re admininstrative claim

98

01112

01112

3/12/2009

Delgado

McNutt

Hammerle/Fein/

Rotella/Borda

Margolin patent

infringement claim

X38

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA technical expert to

NASA attorneys evaluating admininstrative claim

 

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

99

01113

01125

3/13/2009

Borda/Graham/

McNutt/Rotella

 

 

Admin claim

Optima denial

letter BR Draft

Borda-JSM Rev

clean, Optima

denial letter BR

draft

Borda/JSM Rev

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys forwarding revisions to draft of letter

denying admininstrative claim

100

01126

01130

3/13/2009

McNutt

Hammerle

Borda/Ray/Graham

Optima denial letter

(Margolin claim)

Optima denial

letter final

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys forwarding revisions to draft of letter

denying admininstrative claim

101

01131

01135

3/13/2009

Hammerle

McNutt

Borda/Ray/Graham

Optima denial letter

(Margolin claim)

Optima denial

letter final

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys fowarding revisions to letter denying

admininstrative claim

102

01136

01137

3/13/2009

McNutt

Hammerle

Borda/Ray/Graham

Optima denial letter

(Margolin claim)

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re admininstrative claim evaluation

103

01138

01139

3/18/2009

McNutt

Graham/Borda

 

FOIA 2008-270

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re Margolin FOIA request

104

01142

01142

10/1/2008

McNutt

Adams

 

Offer to compromise

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to compromise

admininstrative claim with NASA

105

01143

01143

9/30/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Response to your

most recent letter

 

(b)(4)

Mentions Optima's offer to settle admininstrative

claim with NASA (contained in B5 set: 01140‑

00916)

106

01152

01152

9/30/2008

Adams

McNutt

 

Response to your

most recent letter

 

(b) (4)

Mentions Optima's offer to settle admininstrative

claim with NASA (contained in B5 set: 01149‑

01153)

 

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

107

01154

01155

4/22/2009

McNutt

Robinson

Borda/Rotella/

Graham

FOIA 2008-270

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA FOIA

Office representative re Margolin FOIA request

108

01156

01157

7/17/2008

Galus

Rotella

Mark/Blackburn

Margolin FOIA

Request

 

(b)(5)

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re Margolin FOIA request

109

01158

01158

7/17/2008

Galus

Rotella

Bayer/Blackburn

 

11 attachments  comprising file history of

Patent No. 5,566,073

 

Internal email from NASA attorney to NASA

attorneys re patent file history

110

01680

01682

7/17/2008

Helen M. Galus

Robert F. Rotella

Michael L Mark,

Linda B. Blackburn,

Kathy Bayer

RE: Margolin FOIA

request

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re applicability of

FOIA exemption to certain documents

111

01687

01687

Attachment to July 31, 2008 email

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda

Robert F. Rotella

FW: Margolin Letter

 

(b)(5)

Preliminary draft of letter to Mr. Margolin

112

01688

01688

8/5/2008

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella

Richard W. Sherman

Jed Margolin's patent Infringement claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re discussions with  Mr. Margolin

113

01690

01690

8/5/2008

Kenneth H.

Goetzke

Robert F. Rotella

 

Helen M. Galus

Pending or hreatened

Litigation Report

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re Optima Technology Group (OTG) claim

114

01691

01691

8/5/2008

Robert F. Rotella

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda

FW:Pending or Threatened Litigation Report.

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re whether

Optima Technology Group claim is reportable

115

01692

01693

8/5/2008

Gary G.

Borda

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

Richard W. Sherman

RE:JedMargolin’s‑

patent infringement

claim -

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re discussions

with Mr. Margolin

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

116

01748

01766

NA

Rapid Imaging

Software, Inc.

NASA Office of

General Counsel

 

 

 

b(4)

Privileged attorney work product reflecting

claims analysis in light of prior art. (Duplicate of

00116-00134)

117

01767

01768

8/7/2008

Kenneth H. Goetzke.

Jan.McNutt, Robert

F. Rotella, Edward K. Fein

Helen M. Galus

Margolin case reportable as threatened legal

action

.

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal-email re whether Optima Technology Group (OTG) claim is reportable

118

01777

01778

8/11/2008

Helen M. Galus

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Linda B. Blackburn

Analysis of Patent No.

5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim

119

01779

01782

Attachment to August 11, 2008 email

Helen M. Galus

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Linda B. Blackburn

Analysis. Of  Patent No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Memorandum of Law, to Barry Gibbens, From: John Stankiewicz, Re: Infringement Analysis for NASA’s Synthetic Vision System, System, dated

3-25-04

120

01783

01792

Attachment to August 11, 2008 email

Helen M.Galus

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Linda B. Blackburn

Analysis of Patent No.

5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Memorandum To: Barry Gibbens. From: Ellis Baggs, Date: July 5, 2005, Re: Reexamination of SVS patent issued to Mr. Jed Margolin

121

01793

01794

8/12/2008

Jan McNutt

Helen M. Galus,

Robert F. Rotella

Linda B. Blackburrn,

Gary G. Borda

RE- Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim

122

01795

01797

8/12/2008

Helen M. Galus

Jan McNutt

Linda B. Blackburn, Gary G. Borda, Robert F. Rotella

RE: Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073.

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of

Infringement claim

 

 


 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

123

01798

01800

8/14/2008

Jan McNutt

Helen M. Galus

Linda B. Blackburn,

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella

RE: Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of

Infringement claim

124

01801

01804

8/14/2008

Helen M. Galus

Jan McNutt

Linda B. Blackburn, Gary G. Borda, Robert

F. Rotella, Michael Nick Madrid, Michael I. Mark, Kenneyh H. Goetzke

RE: Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim

125

01805

01808

8/14/2008

Jan McNutt

Helen M. Galus

Linda B. Blackburn, Gary G. Borda, Robert

F. Rotella, Michael Nick, Michael I.

Mark; Kenneth H.

Goetzke

RE: Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of

Infringement claim

126

01809

01812

8/18/2008

Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein

Gary..G. Garda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Helen M. Galus

RE: Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of

infringement claim

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

127

01813

01816

8/19/2008.

Edward K. Fein

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Helen M. Galus

RE: Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim

128

01817

01821

8/19/2008

Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Helen M. Galus,

Theodore U. Ro,

Kurt G. Hammerle

RE: Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim

129

01822

01826

8/19/2008

Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein

Gary-G, Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Helen M. Galus,

Theodore U. Ro,

Kurt G. Hammerle

 

RE- Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Same email as 01817-01821 (NASA legal office internal analysis of infringement claim)

130

01827

01831

8/20/2008

..Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein

Gary G_Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Helen M. Galus,

Theodore U. Ro,

Kurt G. Harnmerle

RE: Analysis of Patent

No. 5,566,073 73

 

(b)(5)

Same email as 01817-01821 (NASA legal office internal analysis of infringement claim)

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

131

01832

01836

8/21/2008

Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Helen M. Galus,

Theodore U. Ro,

Kurt G. Hammerle.

RE: Analysis of Patent No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Same email as 01817-01821(NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim)

132

01837

01841

8/22/2008

Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Helen M. Galus,

Theodore U. Ro,

Kurt G. Hammerle

RE: Analysis of Patent No. 5,566,073

 

(b)(5)

Same email as 01817-01821(NASA legal office.

internal email re analysis of infringement claim)

133

01842

01843

10/6/08

McNutt

Rotella

Borda

FW: Optima

Technology Group -

Margolin Patents

 

b(4)

Email from NASA counsel fowarding

communication containing privileged attorney

work product provided by RIS. (Duplicate of

00241-00242)

134

01844

01859

NA

Rapid Imaging

Software, Inc.

NASA Office of

General Counsel

 

 

 

b(4)

Technical document, the identification of which

reflects the privileged legal opinion and attorney

work product of RIS in evaluating the validity of

certain patent claims. (Duplicate of 00243-00258)

135

01867

01954

NA

Rapid Imaging

Software, Inc.

NASA Office of

General Counsel

 

 

 

b(4)

Technical document, the identification of which

reflects the privileged legal opinion and attorney

work product of RIS in evaluating the validity of certain patent claims. (Duplicate of 00266-00354)

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

136

01955

01959

NA

Rapid Imaging

Software, Inc.

NASA Office of

General Counsel

 

 

 

b(4)

Technical document, the identification of which

reflects the privileged legal opinion and attorney

work product of RIS in evaluating the validity of

certain patent claims. (Duplicate of 00355-00359)

 

137

01978

01979

10/16/2008

Gary G. Borda

Edward K.. Fein,

 Mark W. Homer

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella,

David A. Samuels

Admin Claim for

Patent Infringement-

Optima Technology

Group

Patent 5904724 Margolin.pdf

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim

138

01995

01997

10/21/2008

Mark W. Homer

Gary G. Borda

 

FW: UAV Patent

Infringement Issue

Patent 5904724 Margolin.jd.pdf

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

139

02012

02014

10/21/2008

Gary G. Borda

Mark W. Homer,

Edward K. Fein

 

Robert F. Rotella

FW: UAV Patent Infringement issue

Patent 5904724 Margolin.jd.pdf

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

140

02029

02014

10/23/2008

Robert F. Rotella

Mark W. Homer

Gary G. Borda

RE: UAV Patent Infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

141

02032

02034

10/23/2008

Mark W. Homer

Robert F. Rotella

Gary G. Borda

RE: UAV Patent Infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

142

02035

02035

10/24/2008

Robert F. Rotella

John H. Del Frate

Mark W. Homer,

Gary G. Borda

RE: UAV Patent Infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

143

02036

02036

10/27/2008

John H. Del Frate

Robert F. Rotella

 

RE: UAV Patent Infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

144

02037

02037

10/28/2008

John H. Del Frate

Robert F. Rotella

 

RE: UAV Patent

Infringement Issue

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

 


 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

145

02038

02054

Attachment to October 28, 2008 email

John H. Del Frate

Robett. F. Rotella

 

RE: UAV Patent

Infringement Issue

 

(b)(5)

US Patent_UAV_comments.doc - text version of Patent 5904724 with comments on claim analysis inserted

146

02055

02056

10/29/2008

Robert F. Rotella

John H. Del Frate

Mark W. Homer,

Gary G. Borda

RE: UAV Patent

Infringement Issue

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

147

02057

02058

1/21/2009

Jan McNutt

Francisco J. Delgado

Steven E.

Fredrickson,

Pedro A Martinez,

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Edward K. Fein

RE: Optima admin

claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

148

02059

02060

1/21/2009

Francisco J.

Delgado

Jan McNutt

Steven E.

Fredrickson,

Pedro A Martinez,

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Edward K. Fein

RE: Optima admin

claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

149

02061

02061

1/22/2009

Jan McNutt

Gary G Borda

Robert F. Rotella

Courtney B.

Graham

Margolin Claim and

FOIA

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re handling of

FOIA request of Jed Margolin

150

02062

02062

1/22/2009

Courtney B. Graham

Jan McNutt;

Gary G. Borda

Robert F. Rotella

RE: Margolin Claim

and FOIA

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re handling of

FOIA request of Jed Margolin

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

151

02063

02063

1/23/2008

Jan McNutt

Courtney B. Graham, Gary G. Borda

Robert F. Rotella

RE: Margolin Claim

and FOIA

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email  re handling  of

FOIA request of Jed Margolin

152

02064

02065

1/21/2009

Francisco J.

Delgado

Jan McNutt

Steven E.

Fredrickson,

Pedro A Martinez,

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Edward K. Fein

RE: Optima admin

claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

153

02066

02068

1/23/2009

Francisco J.

Delgado

Jan McNutt

Steven E.

Fredrickson,

Pedro A Martinez,

Gary G. Borda, Robert F. Rotella, Edward K. Fein 

RE: Optima admin

claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

154

02069

02082

1/23/2009

Robert F. Rotella

Jan McNutt

 

Del Frate’s

Comments.doc

 

(b)(5)

Text version of Patent 5904724 with comments

on claim analysis inserted

155

02083

02086

'1/23/2009

Jan McNutt

Francisco J. Delgado,

Kurt G Harnmerle

Steven E.

Fredrickson,

Pedro A Martinez,

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella;

Edward K. Fein

RE: Optima admin

claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

 

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

156

02087

02100

Attachment to January 23,

2009 email

Jan McNutt

Francisco J.  Delgado, Kurt G. Hammerle

Steven E:

Fredrickson,

Pedro A Martinez.,

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella, Edward K. Fein

RE: Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Del Frate's Comments.doc - Email of January 23,

2009 from Robert F. Rotella to Jan McNutt (text

version of Patent 5904724 with comments on claim analysis inserted)

157

02101

02105

1/23/2009

Gary G. Borda

Kurt G. Hammerle

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

RE: Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

158

02106

02119

Attachment to January 23,

2009 email

Gary G. Borda

Kurt G.  Hammerle

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

RE: Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Del Frate's Comments.doc' Email of January 23,

2009 from Robert F. Rotella to Jan McNutt (text

Version of Paterif 5904724 with comments on

analysis inserted)

I59

02120

02121

Attachment to January 23,

2009 email

Gary G. Borda

Kurt G. Hammerle

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

RE: Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

Admin Claim for Patent Infringement - Optima

technology Group - Email of October 16,.2008

from Gary G. Borda to Edward K. Fein and Mark Homer (NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim)

160

02122

02124

Attachment to January 23,

2009 email

Gary G.Borda

Kurt G. Hammerle

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

RE: Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

FW: UAV Patent Infringement Issue - Email of

October 21, 2008 from Gary G._Borda to Mark W.

Homer and Edward K. Fein (NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis)

161

02125

02129

Attachment to

January 23,

2009 email

Gary G. Borda

Kurt G. Hammerle

Jan McNutt

Robert F. Rotella

RE: Optima admin claim

 

(b)(5)

RE: UAV Patent Infringement Issue - Email of

October  31, 2008 from Edward K. Feint to

Francisco J. Delgado (NASA internal email re

patent claim analysis)

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

162

02159

02159

2/5/2009

Kurt G. Hammerle

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

Edward K. Fein,

Gary G. Borda

Updated Status on Margolin Patent Infringement Claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

163

02160

02160

2/6/2009

Jan McNutt

Kurt G. Hammerle, Robert F. Rotella

Edward K. Fein,

Courtney B. Graham

Updated Status on Margolin Patent Infringement Claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

164

02161

02162

2/6/2009

Gary G. Borda

Kurt G. Hammerle,

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

Edward K. Fein,

Gary G. Borda

Updated Status on Margolin Patent Infringement Claim

 

(b)(5)

 

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

 

 

165

02163

02164

2/6/2009

Edward K. Fein.

Gary G. Borda, Kurt G. Hammerle, Jan McNutt, Robert F. Rotella

Courtney B. Graham

 

Updated Status on Margolin Patent Infringement Claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

 

166

02289

02290

2/20/2009

Kurt G. Hammerle

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda,

Edward K. Fein,

Francisco J..Delgado

FW: File wrapper for 5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

167

02291

02292

2/20/2009

Edward K. Fein

Kurt G. Hammerle,

Robert F: Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda,

Francisco J. Delgado

RE: File wrapper for 5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

168

02293

02294

2/20/2009

Francisco J.

Delgado

Edward K: Fein, Kurt G. Harnmerle,, Robert F. Rotella, Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda

RE: File wrapper for 5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

 

169

02295

02297

2/23/2009

Gary G Borda

Kurt G. Hammerle,

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein

RE: File wrapper for 5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

 

170

02298

02300

2/23/2009

Francisco J. Delgado

Kurt G. Hammerle,

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda

RE: File wrapper for 5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

 

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

171

02301

02303

2/23/2009

Kurt G. Hammerle

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda, Edward K. Fein, Francisco J. Delgado

RE: File wrapper for

5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

172

02304

02311

Attachment to February 23, 2009 email

Kurt G. Hammerle

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda,

Edward K.. Fein, Francisco J. Delgado

RE: File wrapper for

5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

Delgado feedback -Claims_Chart_of_US_Patent_ 5904724 23 Feb 2009.doc

173

02312

02315

2/24/2009

Gary G..Borda

Kurt G. Hammerle, Robert F. Rote1la,

Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein,

Francisco J Delgado,

Courtney B Graham.

RE: File wrapper for

5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

174

02316

02319

3/6/2009

Robert F. Rotella

Kurt G. Hammerle

Gary G. Borda,  Jan McNutt, Courtney B. Graham

RE: File wrapper for

5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

175

02320

02323

3/6/2009

Robert F. Rotella

Kurt G. Hammerle

 

RE: File wrapper for

5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

176

02324

02327

3/6/2009

Kurt .Hammerle

Robert R Rotella

 

RE: File wrapper for

5,904,724

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re patent claim analysis

177

02328

02328

3/9/2009

Robert F. Rotella

Gary G. Borda,

Courtney B. Graham,

Jan McNutt

Kurt G. Hammerle

Draft letter denying

Optima/Margolin

administrative claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email forwarding 1st

draft of denial letter

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

178

02329

02333

Attachment to March 9,  2009 email

 

 

 

Robert F. Rotella.

Gary G. Borda,

Courtney B. Graham,

Jan McNutt

 

Kurt G Hammerle

Draft letter denying

Optima/Margolin

administrative claim

 

 

(b)(5)

DRAFT Optima Denial letter

179

02334

02334

3/12/2009

Gary G. Borda

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

 

Admin Claim

 

 

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email forwarding Borda revisions to 1st draft of denial letter

180

02335

02340

Attachment to March 12, 2009 email

Gary G. Borda

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

 

Admin Claim

 

(b)(5)

Optima Denial Letter BR DRAFT GB Rev.doc

181

02341

02341

3/12/2009

Jan McNutt

Francisco J. Delgado

Kurt G. Hammerlee, Robert F. Rotella, Gary G. Borda

Margolin Patent

Infringement Claim - X38

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal mail re analysis of infringement claim

182

02342

02342

3/12/2009

Jan  McNutt

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella

Courtney B. Graham

Admin claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email forwarding McNutt revisions to 1st draft of denial letter

183

02343

02348

Attachment to March 12, 2009

Email

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella:

Courtney B. Graham

Admin Claim

 

(b)(5)

Optima Denial Letter BR DRAFT GB-JSM Rev.doc

184

02349

02349

3/12/2009

F rancisco J. Delgado

Jan McNutt

Kurt G. Hammerle,

Edward K. Fein,

Robert F. Rotella,

Gary G. Borda

 

Margolin Patent

Infringement Claim - X38

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim

 

 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

185

02350

02352

3/13/2009

Gary G. Borda

Courtney B. Graham,

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

 

 

Admin Claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email forwarding final DRAFT of denial letter

186

02353

02356

Attachment to March 13, 2009

email

Gary.G. Borda

Courtney B. Graham,

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

 

Admin Claim

 

(b)(5)

Optima denial letter BR DRAFT GB-JSM Rev_clean.doc

187

02357

02362

Attachment to March 13, 2009

email

Gary G. Borda

Courtney B. Graham,

Jan McNutt,

Robert Rotella

 

Admin Claim

.

(b)(5)

Optima denial letter BR DRAFT GB-JSM Rev_clean.doc

188

02365

02366

4/22/2009

Jan McNutt

Kellie N. Robinson

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella,

Courtney B. Graham.

RE: FIA 2008-270

 

(b)(5)

NASA internal email re handling of Margolin FOIA claim

189

02368

02369

7/15/2009

Jan McNutt

Robert F. Rotella

Gary G. Borda,

Courtney B.

Graham

FW: AA/2009-00316

FOIA Appeal: re

Patents for Method

and Apparatus for

Remotely Piloting an

Aircraft

222009-00316-pdf

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re Margolin FOIA appeal

 

190

02370

02371

Attachment to July 15, 2009 email

Jan McNutt

Robert F. Rotella

Gary G. Borda,

Courtney B.

Graham

FW: AA/-2009-00316

FOIA Appeal: re

Patents for Method

and Apparatus for

Remotely Piloting an

Aircraft

 

(b)(5)

Email from margolin to exec.sec.pdf - internal

email forwarding and commenting on Margolin

FOIA Appeal

 

 


 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

191

02393

02395

7/16/2009

Robert F. Rotella

Jan McNutt

 

FW: UAV.Patent Infringement issue

Patent 5904724

Margolin.jd.pdf

(b)(5)

Forwarding NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim

192

02410

.02410

7/16/2009

Robert F. Rotella

Jan McNutt

 

FW: UAV.Patent Infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

Forwarding NASA internal email re patent claim analysis

193

02411

02428

Attachment to July 16, 2009 email

Robert F. Rotella

Jan McNutt

 

FW: UAV.Patent Infringement issue

 

(b)(5)

US Patent_UAV_comments.doc - Text version of Patent 5904724 with comments on claim analysis inserted

194

02429

02429

8/12/2009

Courtney B. Graham

Gary G. Borda, Jan McNutt, Robert F.

Rotella, Kurt G. Hammerle, Edward

K. Fein, Mark W.  Horner

Bernard J. Roan,

Jay Steptoe,

Richard W. Sherman

ACTION REQUIRED:

Margolin FOIA Suit

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re preparation of litigation report for Margolin FOIA suit against NASA filed in Nevada

195

02430

02431

8/12/2009

Courtney B.

Graham

Gary G. Borda, Jan

McNutt; Robert F.

Rotella, Kurt G.

Hammerle; Edward

K. Fein

Mark W. Horner

FW: ACTION

REQUIRED: Margolin

FOIA Suit

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re preparation of litigation report for Margolin FOIA suit against NASA filed in Nevada

196

02432

02432

8/5/2008

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella

Richard W. Sherman.

Jed Margolin’s patent infringement claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re discussions with Mr. Margolin

197

02433

02433

8/5/2008

Robert F. Rotella

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda

FW: Pending or Threatened Litigation Report

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re whether Optima Technology Group (OTG) claim is reportable

 


 

 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

198

02543

02543

8/5/2008

Robert Adams-OTG

Jan McNutt

 

FW: Jan, please forward me a copy of the letter that you

stated was sent out last Friday...OFFER TO

COMPROMISE, SUBJECT TO RULE 408 FED. R. EVID.

 

(b)(4)

Discussion with Optima Technology Group re their offer to compromise (resolve the infringement matter)

199

02544

02551

Attachment to August 5, 2009 Email

Robert Adams-OTG

Jan McNutt

 

FW: Jan, please forward me a copy of the letter that you

stated was sent out last Friday...OFFER TO

COMPROMISE, SUBJECT TO RULE 408 FED. R. EVID.

 

(b)(4)

2qbzwn6m.pdf - Non-Exclusive Patent License Agreement from Optima to 3rd party

200

02552

02572

Attachment to August 5, 2008 Email

Robert Adams-OTG

Jan.McNutt

 

FW: Jan, please forward me a copy of the letter that you

stated was sent out last Friday...OFFER TO

COMPROMISE, SUBJECT TO RULE 408 FED. R. EVID.

 

 

(b)(4)

geneva1.pdf - cover letter and Non-Exclusive Patent License Agreement from Optima to 3rd party

201

02573

02574

8/6/2008

Gary G. Borda

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

Richard W. Sherman

RE; Jed Margolin's

patent infringement

claim

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re discussions with Mr. Margolin

 

 


 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

202

02575

02576

8/6/2008

Jan McNutt

Robert Adams-OTG

 

Re: Jan, please forward me a copy of the letter that you stated was sent out Friday...OFFER TO

COMPROMISE, SUBJECT TO RULE 408 FED. R. EVID.

Optima Letter

20080801.pdf

(b)(4)

Discussion with Optima Technology Group re their offer to compromise (resolve the infringement matter)

203

02580

02581

8/6/2008

Robert Adams-OTG

Jan McNutt

 

Re: Jan, please forward me a copy of the letter that you stated was sent out last Friday... OFFER TO COMPROMISE, SUBJECT TO RULE 408 FED. R. EVID.

jm_assign.pdf

(b)(4)

Discussion with Optima Technology Group re their offer to compromise (resolve the infringement matter)

204

02583

02585

8/6/2008

Gary G. Borda

Jan McNutt

 

 

Re: Jan, please forward me a copy of the letter that you stated was sent out last Friday... OFFER TO COMPROMISE, SUBJECT TO RULE 408 FED. R. EVID.

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re Discussions

with Optima Technology Group re their offer to

compromise (resolve the infringement matter)

 


 

 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

205

02586

02588

8/6/2008

Jan McNutt

Gary G. Borda

 

Re: Jan, please forward me a copy of the letter that you stated was sent out last  Friday...OFFER TO COMPROMISE,

SUBJECT TO RULE 408 FED.R. EVID.

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re Discussions

With Optima Technology Group re their offer to compromise (resolve the infringement matter)

206

02589

02589

8/6/2008

Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella

Patent, Infringement

Claim from Jed Margolin;  NASA Case

No. I-222

Margolin

FOIA.pdf, Letter

from Optima

20080714.pdf

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re: analysis of infringement claim.

207

02590

02590

Attachment to August 6, 2008 email

Jan McNutt

Edward K. Fein

Gary G. Borda,

Robert F. Rotella

Patent Infringement claim from Jed Margolin; NASA case I-222

 

(b)(5)

Kennedy to JSC.pdf - Letter dated February 10, 2004 from HQ attorney Kennedy to JSC attorney Fein:, Subject: Administrative Claim of Jed Margolin for Infringement of U.S. Patent No. 5,904,724

208

02648

02649

8/6/2008

Helen M. Galus

Jan McNutt

 

RE: Trade Secret

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re analysis of infringement claim

209

02650

02652

8/6/2008

Gary G. Borda

Jan McNutt

 

Re: Jan, please forward me a copy of the letter that.you stated was sent out last Friday ... OFFER TO COMPROMISE, SUBJECT TO RULE 408 FED. R. EVID:

 

(b)(5)

NASA legal office internal email re Discussions

with Optima Technology Group re their offer to

compromise (resolve the infringement matter).

 

 


 

 

 

A

B

C

D

E

F

G

H

I

J

1

Bates # Start

Bates # End

Date

Sender

Recipient

CC

Subject

Attachments (if not listed separately)

FOIA Exemption Claimed

Notes

210

02653

02655

8/7/2008

Kathleen Mulville

Spear

Jan McNutt,

Robert F. Rotella

Gary G. Borda,

James A Reistrap

RE: Audit of NASA

Financial Statement FY 2008

 

(b((5)

NASA legal office email re whether Optima Technology Group (OTG) claim is reportable

211

02656

02657

8/11/2008

Helen M. Galus

Robert F. Rotella,

Jan McNutt

Linda B. Blackburn

Analysis of Patent No. 5,566,073